American Way Smokehouse - Kansas City BBQ

We stopped in for lunch and had a great experience overall. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the service was top-notch — friendly and attentive. We ordered the burnt ends, sausage, and pulled pork, with mac ‘n’ cheese and beans on the side. The sausage was pretty standard for a BBQ spot. The burnt ends were a bit too fatty for my taste — some folks might love that, but I prefer a more balanced meat-to-fat ratio. The pulled pork was good, though a few bites were a little on the bland side. The real standouts were the beans and the cookies — absolutely delicious! I’ll definitely be back to try more of the menu. Worth the visit!

My friends raved about this place knowing I’m a sucker for bbq , so when they invited me, I had to join… But really, just left disappointed…. No liquor/mixed drink options… just beer or soda. I like a good whisky with my bbq … Service was great, people polite. Food came quickly… But the food, oh the food….. The sauce, I can’t describe. My wife opted for ketchup like a 5 year old. When I tried it , it was quickly apparent why. It’s gross. I can’t describe it other than fermented grapes mixed with molasses and vinegar … 0 stars The potato salad, strong mustard flavor. Not the greatest… 2 stars The beans, not spectacular, but not terrible… just Meh …. 3 stars But the biggest disappointment was the meat…. No juice to be seen for miles , dryer than a bounty paper towel . Although I’ll give them , the brisket was tender to break up , just dry as can be . Same for the ham. Smoky flavor , but since the sauce was 🗑️ I couldn’t even use it to dampen the meat. 2 stars if I’m being generous. Lastly, the cookie. Perhaps the highlight of the entire visit. We had the grape jam thumbprint cookie. Large, well cooked and took me back to my childhood. Easy 5 stars All in all, subpar…. That’s 45$ i won’t get back. I didn’t have high hopes for a strip mall BBQ place , and I wasn’t wrong….

The food and portion sizes were incredible! The sauce selection was extensive and flavorful - I loved the Alabama White Sauce and Chipotle! All made in house. Jennifer was extremely kind and helpful and added to our experience. We’ll definitely be back!

Stopped by the American Way Smokehouse while my friends and family were antiquing next door. The food was great, I had smoked chicken on a cheese fry. I also tried one of their sauces and some of the seasoning. Both were tasty. The prices are pretty resonable, under $20 for food, a drink, and a tip. That's pretty amazing these days.

American Way Smokehouse is a hidden gem in Independence. The smoked meats are incredibly tender and juicy—whether it’s brisket, burnt ends, or pulled pork, every bite is packed with rich, smoky flavor. The sides are just as impressive: the Backyard Beans are hearty and delicious with chunks of meat. What really sets this place apart is the attention to detail. You can tell everything is made with care, from the house-made sauces to the fresh-baked cookies in the bakery. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the cozy, patriotic atmosphere makes it feel like home. Whether you’re grabbing lunch or treating friends to a casual dinner, this spot delivers every time. Highly recommend!

Came in and got the brisket and turkey and it was very good with nice smoky flavor, tried the spicy sauce as well and it was very good. The backyard beans and potato salad were great sides as well. Jennifer was the one who took my order and she was very nice and helpful! All around great environment and friendly staff!

Great service, atmosphere and excellent food. Adjacent to an antique shop which bring you back in time and unique combinations. We will definitely be back! Thank you so much for this dining experience. Food was all gone no leftovers