Citarella Gourmet Market - East Hampton

Citarella is hands down the best gourmet market in East Hampton. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a vibrant selection of fresh seafood, prime meats, artisanal cheeses, and farm-fresh produce. The quality is unmatched and everything is beautifully displayed. I always find exactly what I need, whether I’m planning a dinner party or just picking up something quick. Their prepared foods section is incredible—fresh, flavorful, and perfect for when you’re on the go. The staff is helpful, friendly, and clearly take pride in what they do. I especially appreciate their selection of organic items and specialty groceries you won’t find anywhere else in the Hamptons. Citarella is a true gem for food lovers and anyone who appreciates high-end ingredients and top-notch service. If you’re searching for the best gourmet grocery store in East Hampton, Citarella is your go-to destination. Highly recommend!

I love their pre-made meals. Very good selection of fresh produce seafood and meats are amazing too. I hope to be back to try again

Love going here for my meats and produce. Ive had hit or miss pre-made food items. The Mac and cheese tasted like someone dumped nutmeg into it. Overpowered the dish and I had to throw it out. The pesto pasta was gummy. Could just be an off day. But the meats and produce are great

Citarella never disappoints, always great choice for quickly bites, fish tacos from East Hampton were good.

Next time you shop here make sure you check the prices on display and on your receipt. It’s not the first time this happens to me and every time I tell a manager or a worker they play dumb. Today I as walked out I heard another customer complaining about the same thing and employee didn’t do anything

I have been in citarella couple of times. I love everything about their products they always have most unique and organic products. I think they are Erewhon of NYC. Fresh, Healthy, Organic and tasty🙌🏻

This may make me basic but I love a fun grocery store and this one has all the ready to eat food. Good fresh produce selection! The Brooklyn yogurt is amazing. The black and white cookies are fantastic. A really great selection of cheese! Also they have Johnny’s rainbow popsicle’s!