Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream

Omg this is some of the best homemade ice cream in the state of Indiana. If you’re in the area you need to go here with your friends, family, and co workers . You will not be disappointed. The speciality sundaes are enough for two people . The ice cream is so creamy and fresh, with lots of flavors to choose from. I had a hard time deciding so I was able to do a scoop of each. The staff were young , but they were friendly and provide good service. We will definitely be back when we’re in the area. 2025 Went back again and they do not disappoint. They offer two kinds of pup cups, whip cream or ice cream.

Best ice cream I've ever had, and I'm not even from Indiana. The ice cream is stretchier than your usual hard ice cream and it takes longer to melt. We got 7 scoops between the two of us within the span of 24 hours. Chocolate amaretto cheesecake is *chef's kiss* and their cookie dough and coookies and cream...The vanilla base was not your generic vanilla flavor... you can TELL it's homemade. Their base flavors were all a better version of your typical flavors elsewhere, very distinct, AND they have unique flavors that are sooo good.... Excited to try their graham central station when I come back to visit.

A Sweet Paradise! I'm obsessed with Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream! this local gem serves up the creamiest, most delicious homemade ice cream flavors. With over 30 years of experience, they've perfected their craft, offering unique and award-winning flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. What Sets Them Apart: - Unique Flavors: From Graham Central Station to Key Lime Pie, and Banana Brownie, each flavor is carefully crafted to delight your senses. - Homemade Goodness: Their ice cream is made in-house using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring a rich and creamy texture. - Free Samples: Take advantage of their generous sampling policy to discover your new favorite flavor! - Excellent Customer Service: The staff is friendly, patient, and always happy to help. Must-Try Flavors: - Graham Central Station: A graham cracker-based ice cream with a graham cracker swirl and chocolate crunch. - Key Lime Pie: A sweet and tart key lime base with a graham cracker swirl. - Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie: A chocolate and peanut butter-based ice cream with brownie bites and peanut butter drizzle. Overall, Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream is a must-visit destination for ice cream lovers. With its unique flavors, homemade goodness, and excellent customer service, it's a treat you won't want to miss

If you’re an ice cream person, don’t hesitate to stop in this place. The staff was on it! The selection was massive. We all left very satisfied and will be stopping back in next time we are in Indianapolis. Bussin!

My husband and I stopped in for milkshakes and when I got mine (a malt) it was straight liquid like milk. My husband's was a normal texture and so I thought it was a just a mistake. when I went back to ask if they could remake it the girl at the counter said "thats how we make them, I followed the recipe. I can make you another but you'll have to pay for it". The milkshakes are normally great when done right but really poor customer service unfortunately!

I took my kids there for an evening treat. They had so many flavors to choose from which is always fun. They also had two sorbet flavors (lemon and raspberry) and my boys love sorbets. They were both excited about the lemon sorbet! One of them got a scoop of the lemon sorbet and then a scoop of blue moon. We sat on the benches outside. He was so excited about the lemon and right when he made it to the lemon, he fell off off the bench and dropped the ice cream cone upside down onto the cement. He cried over losing that lemon sorbet. I felt so bad for him, I went in and asked if they would put another scoop of lemon sorbet on his cone. They had run out of the lemon sorbet but they kindly gave him another scoop of his choice and gave him a new cone as well. Kindness like this from a business goes a long way. We will definitely be back!!

This might be the best ice cream spot in all of central Indiana. The graham central station was highly recommended in reviews and it didn't disappoint. You can taste that the ice cream is homemade. This is our new ice cream spot every time we want a sweet treat. Highly recommend this place.