Fayetteville Pie Company

Heard great things about this place and am always for exploring locally owned eateries. Came in on a Wed evening and found the place empty; my friend and I were the only customers there. Ended up getting a beef pie (don't remember the name) and strawberry shortcake pie. The beef pie was nothing memorable. It had a dense filling, which surprisingly was quite filling. It had some decent flavor but nothing spectacular. My friend and I half suspected these aren't made daily and perhaps frozen ans then thawed; so that could explain it. The strawberry shortcake pie was surprisingly not quite what I was expecting. Being a pie-centric restaurant, I was expecting a pie crust for it; there wasn't any. Also okay and nothing awesome. The good part was, unlike most American baked- goods, it wasn't overly sweet. The restaurant itself is really nice and well put together. For what I got, I believe the food is slightly overpriced. And judging by the decor of the restuarant I got the vibe they are trying to market a "gourmet" theme, and thus an upcharge in price. Overall - okay eatery. Was great to check the block. Unfortunately nothing enticing enough to want to come back.

May 2021 It's been a few years since I came here. We were passing through and I decided to revisit. Their pies were still good (some better than others), and the service was decent. I had ordered online ahead of time. When I got there at the indicated time, my order had not been assembled yet. I don't know if this was laziness or because I had ordered all unbaked pies and they didn't have refrigerator space to hold completed orders. Something they should work on. Nevertheless, the staff were friendly and I only had to wait a few minutes for my order to be ready. I really like the Honey BBQ Chicken, sweet and spicy with yummy cornbread. The Shepherd's Pie was good, but I don't like how they flavored the meat (exactly how escapes me sadly). Note the cookie crusts for the sweet pies are very thin. I was a little disappointed in the Matcha Pomegranate. They used real matcha, but the flavor was very overpowered by the pomegranate. The Graham Cracker Smacker was very (milk) chocolatey with a few mini marshmallows and very thin graham cracker crust.

We got married on Pi Day (3.14) at the Fayetteville Pie Company and it was better than I could have ever imagined! The location was great for our guests, the food and service was amazing (as usual) and the ambiance and decor was beautiful and served as an amazing backdrop for our ceremony and photos. Leslie was great to work with, she clearly explained how it worked to reserve and use the space after hours and she truly made everything so simple and stress-free! The pies were AMAZING, as they always are, they even had vegetarian options available for our guests. It was a great location for our wedding--everything (ceremony and reception) was done in one place, and we had a great backdrop for our photos and a great ambiance for the whole thing!!! The price for everything was unbeatable, and I would highly recommend The Fayeteville Pie Company, not only for their stellar savory and sweet pies, but also as an event venue--you won't be disappointed!

This is a cute cozy spot , very clean and lovely! We were greeted on the way in and out. Service was great and fast. The Pies 🥧 were just what we were needing on this rainy day. The texture of the breading was mouth watering and with the combination of the mixture inside was yummy

The most delicious place in Fayetteville! Each meal includes a savory and sweet pie. I absolutely love the creative savory pies offered each week. You can also order frozen pies to cook at home! A Fayetteville, even NC, must go to for visiting friends and family! The new place is so gorgeous and so much space to sit with great company! There is also great local beer 😉

This place is a staple of Fayetteville! Excellent food, creative menu options, and a delightful staff. Before COVID, I would take groups of people there for lunch (we would take up the entire second floor seating area) and we always enjoyed ourselves. Now, they make it easy to "grab and go" with pickup orders. Never been disappointed.

Service was fast and friendly, and the menu was simple and easy to read. I love the clean and cozy feel of this gem. I had a pork and mac&cheese pie- the crust was buttery and delicious and the filling was a hearty balance of both ingredients. The pork was a little salty but worked well with the Mac and cheese.